Thomas played by Ryan Reynolds
Runners Up: John Krasinski, Scott Foley
Melissa K. played by Diane Krueger
Runner Up: Kristin Cavallari
Kevin K. played by Christian Bale
Runner Up: Paul Schneider
Shealynn played by Hilary Swank
Runner Up: Angelina Jolie
Cindy played by Drew Barrymore
Runner Up: Cameron Diaz
Kevin A. played by Kenneth Branagh
Runner Up: Michael Biehn
Tyler played by Josh Hutcherson
Cade played by Jonathan Lipnicki
Tate played by Freddie Highmore
Jenna played by Miley Cyrus (for Melissa!)
Wayne played by Michael Keaton
Runner Up: Viggo Mortensen
Rose played by Sela Ward
Runner Up: Ann Cusack
Tommy played by John Cho
Runner Up: Ken Leung
Leah M. played by Sienna Miller
Runner Up: Samaire Armstrong
Paul W. played by Nicolas Cage
Runner Up: Alan Rickman
Brenda played by Cate Blanchett
Runner Up: Meg Ryan
Matt W. played by Matthew McConaughey
Runner Up: Steve Zahn
Kendall played by Kate Hudson
Runner Up: Radha Mitchell
Nick played by Shia LaBeouf
Runner Up: Emile Hirsch
Earnest played by Ryan Gosling
Runner Up: Scott Caan
Lisa played by Elisha Cuthbert
Runner Up: Bryce Dallas Howard
Jody played by Ethan Embry
Tabecca played by Kerri Walsh
Andy played by Chad Michael Murray
Lindsey played by Laura Ramsey
Jeremy played by Jake Gyllenhaal
Runner Up: Balthazar Getty
Michelle D. played by Hayden Panettiere
Chris D. played by Colin Hanks
Jennifer M. played by Jenna Fischer
Matthew M. played by Tobey Maguire
Runner Up: Seth Rogen
Scott played by Ewan McGregor
Runner Up: Rob Rotten
Britney played by Evan Rachel Wood
Runner Up: Lori Petty
Melanie played by Kelly Osbourne
Phil played by Kevin Spacey
Ryan B. played by Scott Caan
Shannon played by Kirsten Dunst
Russ played by Heath Ledger
Ryan S. played by Mark Boone Junior
Chelsea played by Milla Jovovich
Runner Up: Amanda Peet
Jeff played by David Boreanaz
Sarah F. played by Alyson Hannigan
Daryl F. played by
Rachel J. played by Scarlett Johansson
Matt S. played by Zach Braff
Jennifer S. played by Jessica Biel
Colleen played by Sophia Bush
Will S. played by Jason Biggs
Stephanie S. played by Cecile De France
Jay C. played by Patrick Wilson
Carrie played by Kate Beckinsale
Judy played by Zooey Deschanel
Joey played by Mark Ruffalo
Rachel P. played by Ellen Page
Ryan K. played by James McAvoy
Caleb played by Jeremy Piven
Jennifer W. played by Alyssa Milano
Nikole played by Anne Hathaway
Grady played by Hayden Christensen
Sarah G. played by Rebecca Hall
Paul G. played by Breckin Meyer
Richard played by Edward Norton
Tausha played by Keri Russell
Chris played by Josh Hartnett
Trevor played by Paul Walker
Amber played by Maria Menounos
Heather B. played by Anna Faris
Mark B. played by Peter Sarsgaard
Runner Up: Sean William Scott (per Matt S.)
Noah W. played by Craig Slike
Heather W. played by Alison Lohman
Galia played by Megan Fox
Karla C. played by Kristin Kreuk
Zach C. played by Jensen Ackles (per Melissa!)
Jessica R. played by Mena Suvari
Zach R. played by Justin Long
